Thursday, March 27, 2014

A SWNID Spotting: What to Think and Why to Think It about World Vision's Same-Sex Marriage Apology

At the request of gentle readers, we are roused from hibernation to go all SWNID on l'affaire Vision Mondial. Hence, below are ten observations about WV's (not West Virginia's) action and retraction on same-sex marriage. What follows is pedantic, some of it sounding like we are scolding people for not doing their required reading, which we are in fact doing. Those who religiously follow our alter ego in his pathetic social-media posts, all of them lame imitations of noble blogging, will have already read what's here, except for a couple of light revisions for what we hope is clarity. Note well that in the rest of this post, we abandon the SWNIDish style of using the first-person plural inappropriately to refer to the SWNIDish self regally.

1. We should always be careful about bifurcating narratives that pit money against principles. Yes, plenty of true stories are about the conflict between these. But let's be clear: anyone in a responsible position, even responsible only for oneself, ignores financial considerations at one's own peril, usually thereby also imperiling others and, in the case of an organization, the organizational mission. No one who leads a family, let alone a large organization, takes a breath without thinking about its financial impact.

2. [scolding about required reading] As I've noted previously in my brief and infrequent comments in social media on the WV affair, WV faced tremendous pressure to adhere to USAID standards introduced in 2011 that give preference in issuing grants to organizations with nondiscriminatory policies about sexual orientation in hiring. This has clearly been a matter of concern for WV since 2011, since WV, a big recipient of USAID grants, asked USAID for clarifying language, which it never received from USAID or other agents of the US executive branch. [those of you who don't hang on my every word are just missing out]

3. About half of WV's revenue comes from private donations, and we can assume that much of it comes from individual donors, and we can assume that most of that comes from evangelicals. And about half comes from grants, much of that from USAID and other governmental and international organizations that also favor nondiscrimination in hiring in regard to sexual orientation. So the money cuts maybe two ways. WV's financial situation, if compared to two geological entities, is a rock and a hard place.

4. WV's brief "stand" was not taken on the "principle" that they were committed to what is euphemistically and popularly called "marriage equality" but on the "principle" that they won't take a stand where the church universal (mostly the Western, evangelical, Protestant church) is divided. Maybe they were hedging. Or maybe they were serious. Or both. More on this below.

5. For what it's worth, I have observed in myself and others a tendency for those with organizational authority to become insulated from larger, organizationally relevant realities as their attention is captured by immediate organizational concerns, especially those that they believe they can or must manage. How that generalization might apply here is this: the CEO and board of WV have surely faced two attention-capturing matters since 2011: the policy of USAID and the clamor for marriage equality, the latter including some voices in the Christian community. How the insulation works is this: paying so much attention to such things, I don't attend to other relevant factors and so misoverestimate the importance of the things I'm looking at while misunderestimating the importance of the things I'm not looking at. I've paid a price for having done this myself in the past, and I've paid a price for naively assuming that others who had my trust were not doing it. The habit of knowing and questioning one's assumptions is about the hardest habit to acquire.

6. The fact is that despite the considerable noise on the subject in the last couple of years, the Church Universal is hardly divided on the same-sex marriage issue. Even American and European Protestants outside of evangelicalism have not spoken with an organizationally united voice on this subject. If one gets outside the modern Western echo-chamber and listens to global and historic voices--which comprise most of our "great cloud of witnesses"--it speaks loudly and clearly, if inconveniently, on this issue. This may well be the very thing that WV's leadership misunderestimated, having misoverestimated the division of the church and the strength of the revisionist voices on this matter, perhaps unconsciously inclined to do so because doing so offered a way of resolving their dilemma with USAID.

7. So I take seriously and find credible (more credible than many backtracking explanations I've been compelled to accept in other situations in the past, including a couple of my own) WV's statement that it came quickly to realize that its position was out of step and divisive for the Church Universal, which was the very opposite of its intention. I take seriously the idea that people whom the WV leadership respected called members of the WV leadership and respectfully told them that they'd messed up.

8. What disturbs me now is the Manichean tendency of some in the Christian community who advocate same-sex marriage to offer simplistic narratives of the noble, enlightened, principled people against the ignoble, ignorant brokers of power who remind many of their narrow-minded parents. If (and this is a powerful urge in scholarship, where originality and the challenging of authority are the coin of the realm) one wants to take a "principled" Christian stand against the consensus of the faithful globally and through the ages (we like ancient and global Christians when we talk about liturgy, spiritual disciplines, poverty and courage, not so much when we talk about dogma), you may be right to do so. After all, is it not true that in the modern, Western Christian community there are those who advocate such historically un-Christian notions as Arianism, unitariansism, panentheism, universalism, and other matters that Scripture and tradition anathematize? Do we put everything in theological paralysis as a result, meekly shaking our heads that no one can affirm anything about anything theologically because there are "just too many conflicting interpretations"? Or do we justify every revisionist "Christian" position that comes out of scholarly monograph or popular blog? Or do we resolve to stand with the consensus of the faithful until compelled to dissent? I say, for heaven's sake, one should dissent only after taking an extra large dose of self-awareness, seeking large doses of wise counsel, and giving large doses of consideration to all the reasons, even the ugly ones, for which those many witnesses who disagree with the revisionist position do indeed disagree.

9. Yes, you need to know this for the final.

10. Thou shalt not covet.


Brendt said...

Are you also disturbed by the Manichean tendency of some in the Christian community who stand *against* same-sex marriage to offer *equally* simplistic narratives? Or worse yet, to blur the line between Scriptural statement and personal opinion (that may very well be derived from said Scriptural statement, but is still -- nonetheless -- personal opinion)?

Jon Weatherly said...

Yep. I simply hear much more calling out of that, and much less calling out of this.

Brendt said...

Then God has been gracious to your ears. ;-)

Error needs to be confronted no matter what angle it comes from. Rock on.

Jon Weatherly said...

While all comments politely expressed are welcome, we aver as always that a single blog cannot possibly address every evil in the world.

Let us expand on our earlier comment. The Manicheanism of the right tends, in our experience, to be identified by the brokers of power and organs of mainstream communication as coming from the agents of ignorance and repression, whereas the Manicheanism of the left tends to be identified by the brokers of power and organs of mainstream communication as coming from the agents of enlightenment.

More simply: the right-wing fundies have all the articulate critics they need, but the left lacks articulate critics of its own fundamentalism.

Anonymous said...

Learn the meaning of the words overestimate and underestimate. You are underestimating the meaning and value of those two words and MIStakenly making up words, using them where the actual words would do just fine. said...

I thank you so much, those ten facts were extremely interesting and up to the point! Sex-same marriages are really controversial issue. However, humanity should try to get used to it, as there are ore and more sex-same couples and it does not seem that their quantity is going to decrease.

Ann Ann said...

Un altro disegno pulito, il terzo camicia Pescara 2016-2017 è di colore blu scuro con una striscia orizzontale bianca e blu sul davanti. maglia AC milan online
Maglia AS Roma 2017 magliette calcio,
maglie calcio,

Ann Ann said...

The house flag for Chiefs has a liner sewn between its two polyester sides, therefore, this flag is viewable and readable correctly on both sides.Hang your Chiefs House Flag with our banner pole or fly it with our 5' wood flagpole and adjustable flag bracket.sports flags,
nfl flags wholesale,nfl house divided flags,
dallas cowboys american flag,

Rusef Sandi said...

A great forex trading tip is to use an automated system if you feel that you need it. If you're the kind of trader that just can't keep emotion out of it, then using an automated system is definitely for you. It will react to trades and losses accordingly, so you never make a foolish decision. Join us forex signals

Wills Som said...

Trading of foreign currency or Forex trading as it is known is an easy way to make huge money by investing a small amount. There have been many traders who have, made huge profits by using the expert advice from others who have been on the forex platform for many years. Number of reasons makes Forex market the best place for investors who like their money to grow quickly. The highest daily turnover sure makes the Forex market the best place for any new trader to get accustomed with ups and downs of stock market. To know more about forex signals trading. You visit and join us: forex signals

Rashmi S said...

Head hunters in India
Head hunters in Bangalore
Consultancy in Bangalore
Serviced Apartments in Bangalore
SEO Services in Bangalore
SEO Services in India

sumon tripura said...

Another informative blog… Thank you for sharing it… Best of luck for further endeavor too.

Forex Adviser said...

Forex speculation shouldn’t be a straightforward task, which is why traders mustn’t forget to study the trade first earlier than making any precise trade. An intensive foreign currency trading course can assist you be taught all of the in and outs of trading. The professionals can present you the needed studying experience earlier than entering the true world of forex. To know more visit forex signals

Anonymous said...

Fiona makes a grand reappearance.

Anonymous said...

But a Team Fiona t-shirt; don't trade on Forex or buy a flag!

tushar soni said...

Gifts For The Bride
Gifts For The Bride
Gifts For The Bridesmaids
Gifts For Couples & Newlyweds

Unknown said...

Currency exchange trading, Forex trade or FX Trade and eur usd forecast, all terms used to define the trading of one currency for another; for example, the exchanging of U.S. Dollars to British Pounds. In the foreign exchange market, this is considered as pounds trade while simultaneously selling U.S. dollars. Because two currencies are always concerned, currencies are traded in the system of currency pairs, with the evaluating based on the swap rate proposed by brokers in Forex trading marketplace and investors determine buying and selling trends by Forex signals providers around the world.

سماء الحرمين said...

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالاحساء
كشف التسربات بالاحساء
افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالاحساء

SA Car said...

The greater part of our Islamabad branches offer a scope of exceptional, top quality vehicles. Rent a car in Islamabad From wear SUVs to smooth games autos and convertibles, you can undoubtedly locate the correct vehicle to coordinate the vibe your excursion. Observe the drop down menu to discover more data about each branch such the opening hours.